The Case Against Trump Selling Planes to Nigeria for War with Boko Haram
Some in Washington say that the sign of ‘goodwill’ between the two governments is really a vanity project for Nigeria.
For a cool $600 million, Nigeria may become the proud owner of 12 Embraer A-29 Super Tucanos, light attack aircrafts equipped with “wing-mounted machine guns, weapons integration with advanced surveillance… precision-guided bombs, and even air-to-air missiles.”
Nigeria has been trying to acquire the aircraft since 2015; last year the sale nearly went through under the Obama Administration, until the accidental bombing of a displaced persons camp by the Nigerian Air Force resurfaced concerns about Nigeria’s human rights record and the agreement fell through.
The Trump Administration, however, does not seem to share the previous administration’s concerns—and has the congressional support necessary to ratify the deal. Senator Bob Corker, the chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee stated plainly “We need to deal with human rights issues, but not on weapons sales.”
Even though Embraer is originally Brazilian, the planes are manufactured in the United States which means they require US approval for sale to foreign countries.
Read here Nigeria's war with Boko Haram
This new deal has been justified as necessary for Nigeria’s fight against Boko Haram, the Salafi-Jihadist insurgency that has claimed more than 30,000 lives and displaced more than 2.5 million people. However, the sale of the “Super-T’s” is financially irresponsible, operationally and tactically unnecessary, and may actually undermine the counter-terrorism campaign if improperly deployed.
The cost of the twelve planes is expected to constitute half of the annual defense budget of Nigeria. This at a time when the country’s economy is struggling to climb out of a recession, it is already struggling to pay the salaries of soldiers on the frontlines, and there is a significant funding gap for the humanitarian programs in the country’s war-torn North.
The purchase of the Super-T’s is based on the idea that defeating Boko Haram requires sophisticated aircraft. However, that’s simply not the case. As Matthew Page, an independent analyst formerly with the State Department, observes “The Super Tucano is devastatingly effective against covert insurgent bases and groups of fighters operating in remote territory outside government control, as they have in Colombia or Afghanistan. But Boko Haram is a much more slippery target.” Page notes that the group “now operates in the shadows, conducting suicide bombings and other kinds of asymmetric attacks. Since the fall of its Sambisa Forest stronghold, Boko Haram hasn’t been vulnerable to the Super Tucano’s powerful air-to-ground attack capabilities.”
Even more fundamentally, the NAF has also experienced difficulty discerning civilian targets from insurgent targets during its bombing campaigns. The event that stalled the sale under the Obama Administration was the accidental bombing of Rann IDP camp, in Borno State, which killed more than 230 people. Sarah Margon, the Washington Director of Human Rights Watch, told the New York Times that bombing of Rann IDP camp “is not the sole example that we have of the air force dropping munitions on civilians.”
The Super T’s will not remedy the lack of training and professionalism that allowed such abuses to take place. A village—or IDP camp—mistaken as a terrorist camp does not benefit from the improvement in the technical precision of the planes bombing them.
These civilian casualties not only constitute gross human rights abuses, they’re also an effective recruitment mechanism for Boko Haram. A 2016 report done by Finn Church and partner groups found that many Boko Haram members joined because of the abuses that they suffered at the hands of the military. In the report, a majority of respondents cited revenge as their motivation for joining Boko Haram. Civilian casualties and injuries resulting from botched aerial missions, whether conducted with Nigeria’s existing capabilities or with the Super-T’s, will drive recruitment into the insurgency.
Some in Washington suggested that the sale is a sign of “goodwill” between the US and Nigeria; others suggest the purchase is a vanity project for the Nigerian government. Regardless of the motivations behind the sale, it’s clear that it’s ill-advised and potentially counterproductive.
As Atta Barkindo, a researcher on Boko Haram, notes, “fighting extremism” and ensuring stability “is about more than fighting Boko Haram… it’s about engaging with people on the ground; working with local imams and the population” a process that the Super-T’s will be of little use in.
Hilary Matfess is a research analyst and a senior program officer at the Center for Democracy and Development in Abuja, Nigeria.
Ben Hur Plug Up Blog - I belief that if one wants change one have to fight for it and cannot be a bystander .If you have articles, information, thoughts you want to share just send it to me at benhurplugup@gmail.com . Please keep your articles brief, not more than 1000 words or just use bullet points. If you have pictures to go with the articles, that is even better. Towards an excellent Malaysia.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Traitors in the midst of Pakatan Harapan and mostly in DAP
Traitors in Pakatan Harapan , yes many are and do not realize they will be the ones because they are already been compromised during to the...
Popular Post
-
Asian Woman Dies After Shoving An Eel Up Her Golden Gates!! Oh my God! I don’t know whether I want to cringe or be sad for her but...
-
CAUGHT ON VIDEO: WOMAN’S LAST MOMENTS BEFORE FATAL CAR CRASH A SHOCKING livestream video that has gone viral purportedly captures the l...
-
Updated with photo of Tun in Malay costume. Cannot find one with matching one when Tun Siti Hasmah was wearing sari. I guess in these ti...
-
NEWS25 Years-Old Naked Singaporean Lady Gets Injured While Photocopying Her Boobs! ByXiao MintxPosted on May 29, 2017 27th of May, a...
-
Sure, not every woman is walking around with an itchy vagina, but many are. And the reasons why can range from benign (your choice of undie...
-
【WARNING!】Ladies Are Not Allowed To Show Off Their Breasts In Thailand During Songkran Water Festival! Songkran Water Festival is ...
-
'Perspective is a b**** Defiant Kim Kardashian vows to work on 'better lighting and angles' as she slams the haters in foul-mout...
-
Sujatha Call for independent inquiry on Actress Sujatha’s Death Wednesday, August 01, 2007 Manikavasam of Justice party (Parti Kea...
-
Wall Street Breakfast: Investors Assess Geopolitical Risk Read more here Global markets are waiting to take their cues from the U.S. ...
-
The new record holder of the world’s largest penis goes to a 26-year-old Singaporean man who requested to be identified only as Daniel to pr...
No comments:
Post a Comment